Best Tomato Pie Recipe

I absolutely love this Best Tomato Pie Recipe because it perfectly captures the fresh, juicy flavor of summer tomatoes in a savory, cheesy pie that just melts in your mouth. When I first tried it, I was surprised by how simple ingredients like ripe tomatoes, fresh basil, and a cheesy mayo mixture could come together to create something so comforting and delicious. It’s a fantastic recipe to serve when tomatoes are at their peak—you’ll find the combination of textures and flavors truly irresistible.

This recipe shines at casual dinners or potlucks where you want to bring something that’s both homey and a bit special. What makes this the Best Tomato Pie Recipe is not just how delicious it tastes, but how effortlessly it comes together and pleases everyone around the table. Plus, it’s a fun way to use all those ripe tomatoes you might have from the garden or farmers’ market!

this …

Ingredients You’ll Need

Each ingredient plays a key role to make the Best Tomato Pie Recipe stand out. Fresh, ripe tomatoes are the star here, but the blend of cheeses and that mayo-spice combo takes this pie to the next level. I always recommend using quality ingredients for the best results — it makes a noticeable difference.

• Pie shell: Store-bought works fine, but a homemade crust adds extra flakiness and flavor.
• Large tomatoes: Choose firm yet ripe tomatoes to avoid soggy crusts; slicing thickly works best.
• Kosher salt: Enhances the tomatoes’ natural sweetness and helps draw out excess moisture.
• Chopped onion: Adds a subtle pungency and crunch that balances the creamy filling.
• Basil: Fresh and thinly sliced basil brightens up the savory elements with an herby freshness.
• Grated cheese: A mix of sharp cheddar and Monterey Jack is my go-to for melty, flavorful goodness.
• Mayonnaise: Acts as a creamy binder that holds everything together without overwhelming the flavors.
• Hot sauce: Just a splash adds the perfect gentle kick to make your taste buds sit up and notice.
• Freshly ground black pepper: Adds warmth and subtle spice in the background.

Variations

One of the reasons I keep coming back to this Best Tomato Pie Recipe is how easy it is to make it your own. Whether you want it a bit lighter, packed with herbs, or completely vegetarian, there’s a way to tweak it.

• Cheese swap: I love swapping out cheddar for Gruyere when I’m feeling fancy — it adds a lovely nutty depth that impresses every time.
• Herb twist: Try adding thyme or oregano with the basil for a Mediterranean vibe that’s especially good with garden tomatoes.
• Spice level: If you prefer a little more heat, doubling the hot sauce amps the flavor without overpowering the pie.
• Crust options: Gluten-free or whole wheat crusts work just as well if you want to cater to dietary needs or add a rustic touch.

How to Make Best Tomato Pie Recipe

Step 1: Prep and Pre-bake Your Pie Crust

First things first, preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C) and position a rack in the center. If you’re using store-bought pie shell, follow the package instructions or bake it lightly for about 8–10 minutes until it’s just starting to brown—this keeps the crust from getting soggy later. For homemade crust, I like to press it into the pie plate and freeze it for 30 minutes before baking. Then, pop on some foil and pie weights to keep the edges from drooping, bake for 15 minutes, remove the foil, poke a few holes with a fork to vent the steam, and bake for another 10 minutes. This double bake makes sure the crust is beautifully crisp, which is key for the Best Tomato Pie Recipe!

Step 2: Drain and Slice Your Tomatoes

While the crust is baking, slice your tomatoes about 1/2 inch thick. I like to sprinkle them with kosher salt and let them drain in a colander for 10-15 minutes—this is a trick I discovered to avoid watery pies and keep the crust flaky. Don’t skip this step because nothing ruins a tomato pie faster than a soggy bottom!

Step 3: Make the Cheesy Filling

Combine your grated cheese—my favorite combo is sharp cheddar and Monterey Jack—with mayonnaise, thinly sliced basil, chopped onion, hot sauce, and fresh black pepper. This mixture becomes the creamy, flavorful glue holding your tomato pie together. I always give it a good stir to make sure everything is evenly distributed before layering.

Step 4: Assemble and Bake

Layer half of your drained tomato slices in the prebaked crust, then spread half of the cheese mixture over the top. Repeat with the remaining tomatoes and cheese mixture. Bake for about 35-40 minutes until the top is bubbly and golden brown. You’ll know it’s done when it smells heavenly and the cheese has that light brown, melty crust. Let it cool for a bit before slicing—that way, it holds together nicely.

How to Serve Best Tomato Pie Recipe

Garnishes

I love to sprinkle a bit more fresh basil or a handful of chopped chives right on top before serving. It adds such a fresh pop of color and flavor. Sometimes, a drizzle of good-quality olive oil or a light sprinkle of flaky sea salt gives it a nice finishing touch that makes it feel extra special.

Side Dishes

This pie pairs wonderfully with a simple green salad dressed with a lemon vinaigrette or some roasted vegetables to balance the richness. On warmer days, I often serve it alongside grilled chicken or a light soup — it’s incredibly versatile!

Creative Ways to Present

For a casual brunch, I like cutting the pie into small squares and serving it buffet-style with fresh fruit and a mimosa bar. It also makes for an impressive layered appetizer when sliced into wedges and served with crisp crostini for nearby guests to nibble. For special gatherings, garnish each slice with a small tomato and basil leaf for an elegant look.

Make Ahead and Storage

Storing Leftovers

After enjoying your tomato pie, any leftovers store beautifully in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. I’ve learned it’s best to slice it, then cover it well to prevent the crust from getting soggy — and it reheats very nicely!

Freezing

I usually don’t freeze tomato pie because of the fresh tomatoes, but if you want to, wrap it tightly in plastic wrap and foil before freezing for up to 2 months. When ready, thaw overnight in the fridge and heat gently to keep the crust crisp.

Reheating

The best way I’ve found to reheat slices of tomato pie is in a 350°F oven for about 15 minutes or until warmed through and the crust regains some crunch. Avoid microwaving if you want to keep that delightful texture intact.

FAQs

Final Thoughts

This Best Tomato Pie Recipe has become a real favorite in my kitchen because it’s comforting, fresh, and surprisingly easy to pull together—especially when tomatoes are in season. I hope you give it a try and find it as delicious and satisfying as I do. It’s the kind of recipe that brings everyone to the table with smiles, and I’m confident it’ll become one of your go-to tomato dishes too!

Print